Is Crowdsourcing Evil and Other Moot Questions ...

Crowdsourcing, by its very name, encourages a comparison to outsourcing. But when Wired first published the article that entered the term into the popular lexicon, it was far from clear whether the phenomenon would realize its disruptive potential. Three years later it seems increasingly obvious that it will. Aided by a new generation of sophisticated start-ups, ever cheaper creative tools, and — most of all — a recession that is forcing cost-saving measures on businesses, crowdsourcing is rapidly migrating from the fringe to the mainstream.

Witness the upheaval currently afflicting the design industry, sparked by the rise of so-called "spec design" sites like crowdSPRING and 99designs. On these sites customers post creative briefs directly to the community, which then competes to create a design that best fits the clients' needs. A typical "assignment" will draw dozens of submissions. The winner receives a nominal fee (as little as $200), and the client receives a logo or Website design at a fraction of what a professional agency might charge. The losers get zip, which goes a long way to explaining why working on spec (aka 'on speculation," or without guarantee of payment) has always been considered the work of last resort for writers, designers and other creative professionals.

So one might expect crowdSPRING and 99designs to wither away like so many other seemingly ill-conceived Web 2.0 start ups. Instead, they seem to be flourishing. 99designs says it has paid out over $4 million to its community of 30,000 artists, and crowdSPRING expects to be profitable by next year. The success of crowdsourced design has sparked a vibrant, highly emotional debate within the design industry. (The brouhaha will go live at SXSW next week, when I moderate a panel on the subject of spec work in design.)*

Alarmed by the popularity of the spec model, a group of designers formed a protest group called NO!SPEC to persuade their colleagues (and prospective clients) to just say no to design contests. Their effort has not been in vain. The trade group AIGA — composed of some 22,000 designers — has gone so far as to stake out an official position on spec-work: "AIGA strongly discourages the practice of requesting that design work be produced and submitted on a speculative basis in order to be considered for acceptance on a project."

The controversy shifted into high gear last month after Forbes published an airy, one-sided look at crowdSPRING. In over 100 comments to the article one could read persuasive, articulate variations on a single theme: "Fuck you and crowdSPRING too." Several prominent design blogs posted their own jeremiads lambasting crowdSPRING. "Spec work has become a major force in devaluing the perception of graphic design in the business world," writes eyeCinq. "The folks that run these outfits have managed to figure out a way to get thousands of people — some skilled enough to earn a decent living — to work for them gratis. It’s an amazing sleight-of-hand," writes the logo factor.

It would seem that the squabble has united the design community against the barbarians at their gate. And that would seem to bode ill for the future health of the spec sites, right?

Don’t count on it. A similar debate was taking place in the stock photography world when we published “The Rise of Crowdsourcing” back in that bygone era of June 2006. The fact this debate has been largely settled — in favor of the barbarians — speaks volumes about where graphic design, and, for better or worse, most other creative fields, are heading.

I made this explicit comparison on my blog last August. The demand for low-end design has ballooned in recent years alongside the profusion of start-ups and small businesses. Conveniently enough, so has the supply of what we might call "low-end designers" (amateurs, recent grads and the like). According to Forbes there are 80,000 freelance designers in the US alone. Most of these are, proverbially speaking, waiting tables. When someone matches demand and supply, well that's kismet!

iStockphoto and other so-called "microstock" agencies capitalized on a similar disparity. The result was the total disruption of the $2 billion stock photo industry. iStock is now the third-largest purveyor of stock images, and some 96 percent of its "workforce" is comprised of amateurs. In my crowdsourcing book I posed the question of whether stock photography was an isolated case, or just the canary in the coal mine. It was an open question as of April 2008 when I submitted the final changes to my galleys. Now it ain't. The canary is prone, lying motionless on a bed of its own droppings. It looks like it's time to find another mine.

* Two of my co-panelists have written their own distinctive takes on the debate. Please check out Threadless.com's Jeffrey Kalmikoff on the spec debate, as well as Forrester analyst Jeremiah Owyang's advice to designers.

Comments

[Memoir Books]

I would say crowdsourcing is good for our economy right now. I use 99designs.com for my project and i was able to get high quality work done for a price i can afford. The economy fell apart because like the inflation in house prices, everything else is inflated as well. Emerging trends like crowdsourcing are a byproduct of economic adjustment.

[Oconnor27LEA]

It's understandable that cash makes us independent. But how to act if somebody doesn't have cash? The one way only is to try to get the home loans and just student loan.

[dissertation samples]

Thanks for introducing about you and very excellent your performance work style. I really appreciate for this post.

[dissertation topics]

Hi,
Very nice, unique and informative post. Thanks for sharing. Keep up the good work.

[dissertation writers india]

I think is good article and I can see some real parallels between crowdsourcing and the patronage system that existed during the Baroque and early Classical. I appreciate for you

Thanks

[dissertation samples]

HI,,,,
good article I have reading this article is awesome so good work keep it up!!!!

[sildenafil citrate]

what a great blog, congratulations!!!

[tadalafil uk]

I think it's not possible to answer this evil question...

[managerial accounting homework]

I like to use of crowdsourcing and I am better feel after read your article.

Thanking you very much for infomation

[Essay Service]

Hi,
This is an excellent and informative work, this will really helpful for me in future. I like the way you start and then conclude your thoughts. Thanks for this information. I really appreciate your work, keep it up.

[Discount Louis Vuitton]

I would say crowdsourcing is good for our economy right now. I use 99designs.com for my project and i was able to get high quality work done for a price i can afford. The economy fell apart because like the inflation in house prices, everything else is inflated as well. Emerging trends like crowdsourcing are a byproduct of economic adjustment.

[Louis Vuitton Outlet]

Speaking of Crowdsourcing questions...Can someone please help? I am a MBA student from South Africa doing my research report on the supply side of Crowdsourcing.
Does anyone know of any market research that was done on the supply side of crowdsourcing? And , does anyone know of market research surveys on crowdsourcing doing the rounds?
Any help will be appreciated.
Thank you very much

[professional seo]

You'll even get some full 640 x 480, 30 fps video out of the thing, plus some 2-megapixel JPEG images.
It also can be used a carring Spy camera or a PC camera.

[ladies boots]

Excellent and informative work!I can see some real parallels between crowdsourcing and the patronage system .

[Shoes Factory]

thread starter's post is written wonderful. Writing is smooth, dignified rhetoric, won the Wei and Jin Zhu Chao-legacy, but will also promote the Tang, Song was penetrating bone can be seen in their lifetime this Louzhu post.

[Outsourcing Philippines]

Great post. Crowdsourcing is the act of outsourcing tasks.
THanks for sharing your insights.

[Karis]

your good collection and very clean writing. Keep continue your work in future...

Best of Luck

[properties in brisbane]

Is Crowdsourcing Evil and Other Moot Questions ...<-- Wonderful to read!

[ugg store]

What a wonderful article you shared.I found that your article is so constructive and full with life wisdom.You must be a really mature guy!

[bard catheters]

Thanks.. I just got it interesting..

[Dissertation topics]

Excellent Blog! I really admire your thinking and the way you have put these information in this post. Thanks for sharing an informative post.

[first aid kits]

well, I was just passing by and the stuff here is really very interesting. I like it.

[wound dressings]

Interesting, Thank you I just got it know about it very well here.

[Company Logo Design]

This article is best for students to get some info and ideas from it.
please share some more articles related to this topics.

[first aid kits]

great, I really enjoyed at your site.