The Eyes and Ears of the Crowd ...

This one's so obvious I can't believe I didn't already suggest it to my own home team, the New York Yankees. Why rely on professional scouts—few in number, limited in resources—when you can animate the power of the crowd to do the scouting for you. Last week The Wall Street Journal reported on how the St. Louis Cardinals are asking their fans to identify baseball talent that might otherwise go unnoticed.

The "One for the Birds" contest is meant to help the team find talent at smaller, non-Division I colleges that don't get much attention from scouts. Fans file entries by going to the Carindals' Website and filling out a form, including the player's name, statistics and a summarized recommendation of up to 300 words and other information. When the submissions are in, the team plans to send its own scounts to evaluate a handful of the most interesting prospects. ... The winning fan gets a trip to St. Louis to see a pair of games.

I'd like to tease out two themes here. The first is that by offering so little in the way of compensation—one fan gets to see two free games—the Cards are recognizing what's come to be an accepted fact of crowdsourcing efforts: We ain't in it for the money, we do it for the fun.

More interesting, and more important, is something else entirely: The "One for the Birds" program also recognizes that what the crowd excels at isn't so much analysis as it is data collection. This has become a central theme in my book as well. We're entering a period that can be thought of as Crowdsourcing's second iteration, and a big part of that involves downscaling what we expect from the crowd.

I'll close by pointing out a close parallel from a wildly divergent field, journalism. Amanda Michel, my former colleague from our crowdsourced journalism experiment, Assignment Zero, now runs Off the Bus for the Huffington Post. She's also come to recognize that her community works best when it aims small. Proof of this is the recently launched Off the Bus Super Delegate Investigation. Did she ask people to write features about the delegate process? Or to write Op-Eds on whether Super-Dels should go with the will of the people or the will of the party elite? Nope and nope. She gave them a questionnaire and assigned each volunteer to ask a series of uniform questions to every one of the Super Delegates. It's a task that would have overwhelmed the physical resources of any newsroom (though importantly, not its intellectual resources.) But for a few hundred geographically dispersed volunteers it's a breeze, requiring neither training nor a large commitment of time.

These are the kinds of models that hold enormous promise, and that I predict we'll see much more of in coming months and years. Humble in intellectual pretense but ambitious in scope, they are well-suited to that most salient characteristic of a crowd: it has numbers on its side.

Comments

[Digidave]

re: The Cardinals - You are right people aren't in it for the money. They are in it because they love baseball. And perhaps -- they love the Cardinals - their team. Imagine now, the chance to help shape the team. When they go to games they won't just be cheering for their home team - they will be cheering for the team they helped to shape.

That's brand loyalty.

Also: Amanda is freak'n brilliant. I agree: There are some things the crowd can do better and faster than experts. There are some areas where experts still excel. Future experiments will have to continue to find the sweet spots for both.

[Health News]

This is a wonderful site. The things mentioned are unanimous and needs to be appreciated by everyone.

[Air Jordan 1]

I wish more people would write blogs like this that are really fun to read. With all the fluff floating around on the net, it is rare to read a blog like this instead.

[Turbo fire]

Thank for the amazing content on your blog, I am very curious in this article and you have really helped me. I have just told a few of my friends about this on FaceBook and they love your content just as much as I do.

[Louis Vuitton Prefall 2010]

Also: Amanda is freak'n brilliant. I agree: There are some things the crowd can do better and faster than experts. There are some areas where experts still excel. Future experiments will have to continue to find the sweet spots for both.

[クラシックアーガイルニットuggの]

[url=http://www.ugg-rakuten.com/]楽天市場[/url]ホームベースのビジネスを設定し、繁栄、時間を可能にするように感じる良い戦略を実行する必要があります。1 つのものの全体のビジネスを管理する方法の知識は確かに得るです。まあ、チャージ カード、ビジネス問題を設定し、その潜在的な収益を取得するのと思うできます。

[north face coats]

Curtains inadvertently shaking a bit, I suggest more than the sun, and wind.

[Ugg Boots Sale]

AustraliaDiscount Ugg Bootsprofit adjure pictures of handmade and satisfactory cossack that support you advance your panic attacks cozy throughout arctic winters. And why just winters, these affidavit cossack types are complete for summers as well. TheDiscount Ugg Boots are about affidavit boots from Australia that occur to be certainly admired the apple more than for their look caliber as well.
Apart from obtaining glamorous,these boots are uncomplicated in your panic attacks and you will have the ability to airing on them anyplace on earth. truly you don???t even cost to abrasion socks with them. Ugg Classic Tall are certainly acceptable for all occasions. You could possibly aswell allowance them for your infant and abreast types on several occasions like anniversaries, birthdays, Valentines morning etc. Get your self a brace thisUgg Classic Short to obtain a aftertaste of affluence and style. expertise the warmth, softness, and accustomed really feel of our archetypal boots and once more you will apperceive why people these days from all corners with the apple accept collapsed in adulation with them.

As a Cheap Ugg For Sale lineup,Ugg boots are right here to stayBy getting the preliminary preventative actions outlined above, you'll be ensuring your Ugg Bootsboots are prepared for all sorts of conditionsMoreover, inside the earlier 20th century farmers as well employed to put onDiscount Ugg Bootssort of lengthy and protective boots for that exact same objective of maintaining their ft cozy and warm Usually, the boots for fluffy looks and adore In fact, the appeal for these uggs has additional assorted back again the aftermost couple of many years The specific uggs boots are consequently comfortable, infact, Classic Uggs have inspired me to wander to work-1htmlcom'] Ugg cardy [/link],was so typical close to that time that it absolutely was discovered in numerous dictionaries released in Australia close to that time" Fabrication of Sheepskin in developing fabulous and comfy shoes was not limited only with Ugg Boots however Ugg shoes also paved the way in which for that innovation of Ugg Slippers It can be an added action but outcomes in added comfortHowever it is crucial to find out exactly where to purchase very best UGG sheepskin bootsHowever, together with excellent popularity, as Hollywood stars of all ages were observed putting on these cozy shoes.