Nick Carr on the Youtube Star: Required Reading

By Jeff and Alan ...

On Friday Youtube started paying some of the most popular of its videographers. Om Malik, I believe, broke the story. The ever incisive Nicholas Carr of Rough Type, muses over the move to reward the "You Tube elite." This move constitutes somewhat of vindication for Carr, who entered into a highly publicized wager with the Yale Law professor Yochai Benkler last summer over whether social production (aka crowdsourcing) could survive without being eventually sullied by the emergence of a system of monetary rewards.

I've always found the debate a bit beside the point. I call both Wikipedia (which relies on non-monetary rewards) and a model like iStockPhoto (which relies on a combination of monetary and non-monetary compensation) to constitute a fundamentally new mode of production. I call it ... Oh, you know what I call it, don't you. Regardless, Youtube's move is a significant (and overdue) development in the maturation of the crowdsourcing model, and Carr's post provides much food for thought. And if you haven't read the original post by Carr that spawned the wager, it's here. Benkler's reply is here. Oh, and because I'll use any opportunity I can to plug Benkler's book, if you haven't read his The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom, go buy it here, now.

Comments

[Mark Bowness]

Crowdsourcing is certainly an interesting concept and is one that is growing in popularity, www.myfootballclub.co.uk being a prime example. I will be following your blog with interest.

Mark Bowness

[wow power leveling]

Thank u for your advice,i will think about it seriously

[MeadowsALISA29]

Set your own life time more easy take the home loans and all you need.

[Damier Azur Canvas]

I want to take a brief break from Gannett coverage (I'm under slept, having stayed up half the night watching Montana returns roll in.) Last week I appeared in my first virtual Q&A, at a Wired event in our new Second Life digs. The topic, naturally, was crowdsourcing in general and how Linden Lab – the company behind SL – has used crowdsourcing to great advantage. It was great fun, and the audience asked several thoughtful questions, such as Mordant Kepler, who wondered whether minimum wage laws should apply in crowdsourcing. My reply, somewhat abbreviated:

I think there are policy frameworks that we haven't begun to work out. If I'm a turker in Bangladesh, what's my minimum wage? If it's in US dollars and the requesting company is incorporated here, I think the answer would be our minimum wage, but I'm not even sure you could enforce minimum wage on piecework like that, which explains why some people are -- rightfully -- worried about crowdsourcing's implications.

[Cheap Louis Vuitton]

Crowdsourcing is certainly an interesting concept and is one that is growing in popularity, www.myfootballclub.co.uk being a prime example. I will be following your blog with interest.

Mark Bowness